How Do You Use Dried Mushrooms for Thanksgiving?
Here’s your guide to using dried mushrooms for your Thanksgiving dinner, or anytime of the year.
How Do You Use Locally Grown Dried Mushrooms for Thanksgiving?
Well, dried mushrooms are good year-round, and you can apply these techniques to your Thanksgiving dishes. Amherst Mushroom Company grows, harvests, and dries its own mushrooms, and you can turn them into a rich Thanksgiving gravy, savory stuffing, an umami turkey dry rub, homemade green bean casserole, and mushroom-herb compound butter. Because drying concentrates a mushroom’s natural umami, a single1oz bag grown right here in Amherst gives your holiday table deep, slow-cooked flavor without adding hours of prep.
Here are the questions I get asked when working at farmers’ markets.
Besides the Amherst Farmers’ Market, where can I buy your dried mushrooms?
You can buy locally cultivated dried mushrooms (Shiitake and our 6-in-1 mix, as examples) directly from our Amherst farm stand on 214 Pomeroy Lane, just minutes from Hadley, Northampton, Belchertown, and Leverett. You can also order online at amherstmushroom.com for easy pickup at the farm or local delivery in the 01002 ZIP code with a minimum order.
Why should I stock up on dried mushrooms before Thanksgiving?
Dried mushrooms pack a much deeper, umami flavor than fresh mushrooms alone and give you two ingredients in one: tender rehydrated mushrooms and an intensely savory stock. Because they are shelf-stable for a year or more in an airtight container, you can pick them up weeks ahead of the busy Thanksgiving grocery rush in Amherst and Hampshire County without worrying about spoilage.
How do you make Thanksgiving gravy with dried mushrooms?
Steep your dried mushrooms in hot (not boiling) water for 20 to 30 minutes, then strain the dark soaking liquid through a fine-mesh sieve lined with a coffee filter to catch any sediment.
- For traditional turkey gravy: Whisk the strained mushroom liquid straight into your roux alongside pan drippings for a deeper color and richer flavor.
- For vegetarian Thanksgiving gravy: Use the soaking liquid as your sole broth base, simmered with sautéed shallots, fresh thyme, and a splash of soy sauce or tamari.
Can you put dried mushrooms in Thanksgiving stuffing or dressing?
Yes. Add chopped dried mushrooms, or finely chop the rehydrated mushrooms and sauté them in butter with onions, celery, garlic, and sage before folding them into your bread cubes. Swap out one cup of your usual chicken or vegetable stock for the strained mushroom soaking liquid so the bread absorbs savory flavor all the way through.
How do you make a dried mushroom dry rub for a Thanksgiving turkey?
Put three tablespoons of dried mushrooms in a spice grinder, coffee grinder, or high-powered blender until powdery. Mix the mushroom powder with kosher salt (1tsp), cracked black pepper (½ tsp), dried thyme(½ tsp), and rosemary(½ tsp), then rub it all over your turkey—and gently under the skin—the night before roasting. The salt helps crisp the skin while the mushroom powder seasons the meat and elevates your pan drippings.
Can you use dried mushrooms in a green bean casserole? Of course!
Skip the canned condensed soup by building a quick homemade mushroom cream sauce. Sauté chopped rehydrated mushrooms with minced garlic and shallots in butter, whisk in a tablespoon of flour, and slowly pour in heavy cream along with a splash of reserved soaking liquid. Simmer until thick and velvety, toss with blanched green beans, and top with crispy fried shallots.
What is the best way to make mushroom butter for Thanksgiving sides?
Fold one teaspoon of finely ground dried mushroom powder—or finely minced, sautéed rehydrated mushrooms—into a stick of softened unsalted butter with roasted garlic, fresh chives, and flaky sea salt. Roll it in parchment paper, chill until firm, and slice pats over mashed potatoes, local Pioneer Valley roasted squash, and warm dinner rolls.
How do you rehydrate dried mushrooms without losing flavor?
- Soak: Cover dried mushrooms with hot water in a heatproof bowl for 20 to 30 minutes until tender.
- Lift, don’t pour: Lift the mushrooms out with a slotted spoon or your fingers so any grit settles at the bottom. Rinse lightly if needed, pat dry, and chop.
- Save the liquid: Strain the soaking water through a coffee filter or paper towel—never pour it down the drain. It works as instant mushroom stock for gravies, soups, and stuffings.
Can you combine dried mushrooms with fresh mushrooms from Amherst Mushroom Company?
Yes. Pairing our dried mushrooms with fresh Shiitake, Chestnut, Oyster, or Lion’s Mane mushrooms gives you both concentrated umami in your sauces and crisp-tender texture on top of your holiday side dishes.
Do locally grown dried mushrooms make a good Thanksgiving host gift?
If you are traveling out of Amherst or the Pioneer Valley for Thanksgiving, a pack of locally grown dried mushrooms travels easily with no refrigeration required. They make a thoughtful, lightweight host gift that brings a taste of Western Massachusetts to someone else’s kitchen.
How do you order ahead for Thanksgiving pickup at Amherst Mushroom Company?
Skip the crowded supermarket aisles and reserve your dried mushrooms—along with fresh Shiitake, Oyster, Chestnut, and Lion’s Mane mushrooms—directly from our farm in South Amherst.
- Farm Stand Address: 214 Pomeroy Lane, Amherst, MA 01002
- Farm Stand Hours: Monday–Friday, 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Online Pre-Orders & Local Delivery: Order ahead at amherstmushroom.com (free delivery on orders over $50 within the 01002 ZIP code)
- Phone: Call (413) 858-5558 with Thanksgiving order questions